Welcome!

By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.

Sign Up Now!

Bulldogs Debate Page

The flegg side side is stacked with elite level talent.

Young and Teaupa really look like elite playmakers to me.

We need to start giving young guys more opportunities.

These players are perhaps too young for NRL, perhaps they can get more games in reserve grade?

What was really noticable in Flegg was Young, Teaupa and the winger Hayward though some vey accurate long passes. Decision making and execution was spot on.

Galvin is the best passer in the NRL side, but the Teaupa seems to make better decisions and throw better passes.

The young half Conti apparently played well in reserve grade, his defence needs work, but he is a full toolkit halfback.

I am starting to question Burto as our left sided half, while he is great at running and kickng, he doesn't have the passing instincts.

Ideally we want like NRL side playing as well in NRL as the Flegg side do in Flegg.

The Panthers showed that our attack is way better than it was last season, if the defence does its job. The defence turned up most games last season, it is patchy this season.

Overall it looks like it will be a slow build this season, we have a lot of work to do , we need more speed and talent in the side and we need to ensure that the defence turns up every week.
 
Last edited:
I understand what the club is doing, promoting young players to NRL too early can destroy their confidence or break their body.

On the flip side, promoting quality young talent is the best way we can create a premiership window,

Fans and young players can get impatient and sometimes young players will go elsewhere for an opportunity.

Gus is very conservative and this is mostly in the young players interests.

Trying to win with defence takes a lot of energy and comittment, the tank ran empty the last 2 seasons, but the players gave it everything.

This season, we don't seem to have the juice to win with defence every week. Other teams are fitter, their attack was improved and the game is faster.

IMO we need to start giving more talented young guys an opportunity. And some of the veteran players capable of week-to-week NRL need to play a bit of reserve grade to make room for the young guys.

Montoya is in that category, but he might not be the only one.

If there is any sign that the club is going backwards this season, the fans will get impatient. Even if the sign is only match results and ladder position and if we have some bad luck or dud calls.

Fans will like seeing talented young players with a lot of potential getting a shot.
 
Last edited:
Curran wasn't thst bad, but Tuala did a better job of keeping the defence tight on the right.

Dropped balls were slightly unlucky.

We haven't won a day game, perhaps the heat is a factor.

Apparently we have a long intense warm up, or perhaps the day games are simply the games where we turn up expecting an easy win.

It doesn't take a lot to go wrong for things to go wrong, the ball bounces for the team on top.

Hayward has had sone good attempts at a 40/20, but hasn't been able to buy a bounce.

Leo definately needed the run, Hughes was good.
 
The only times Sua has played centre in reserve grade this season, he has played left.

We possibly have 4 left centres, Xerri, Burton, Critter and Sua. Sua is very good at centre.

Tuala being ruled out late is the perfect storm becuase i don't think we could have added a player like Readon to the team.

For a guy filling in a short notice Curran did a reasonable job in defence, the lack of Tuala was very noticeable in attack,

O'Meley played left centre in reserves, he can probably play both sides.

If Critter isn't right, Readon is an option at right centre.

Apart from Montoya the performance wasn't as bad as it looked. The Parra forwards just ran a lot harder than we expected, Volkman defended way better at 5/8 than we expected.

The opposition surpised us and we really missed King and Tuala who were 2 of our better players.

People are going to think that Kiks is a bit of a flat track bully becuase he only had 8 runs for 48 metres. But he did make 36 tackles and he missed anither 4.

When we are behind in a game on yardage sets we struggle to get Kiks into the game. Perhaps we should have the option of giving him a rest on the bench switching Presto to the left and using someone like Hopoi or Spinks on the right?

We mostly lost the game in the forwards, but a few unforced errors didn't help our casue.

Parra were not the version of Parra we could have out 50 on. If we played with intensity for the first 30 mins, that might have been different.

Parra just put in a lot of hard work and got a bit lucky.

You don't need to panic, Cirro hasn't gone crazy and the team isn't about to fall apart. Broncos will not be easy, the vibe-o-meter isn't getting a read on that game, but hopefully Critter on the right is enough for us to eek out a narrow win in a close tight game.
 
Last edited:
Kiks was trying to get involved in yardage sets, we tended to play away from him.

Galvin is doing more of the kicks, there will be a reason for that. Often our yardage sets are finishing on the right and Kiks isn't back for the early tackles.

A penetrating run by a winger or fullback, a penalty of 6 again would get Kiks into the game. Not many 6 agains that game at times Parra had a skinny 10 or held us down. At times we didn't fight hard enough for a quick PTB.

Right centre is hard to play in attack and defense, especially with Montoya on the wing. People underestimate what a great job Tuala did.

Xerri is a really great left centre but struggled on the right, he has had more experience on the right than Sua.

The defensive workload is what makes playing on the right hard. Curran did that part, but he couldn't manage the attacking side,

We are very lucky to have 2 guys who can play right centre very well, Tuala and Critter, Kiraz is ok, and young Reado goes ok.

We could have switched Kiraz to right centre and started Sua on the left wing. Kiraz hasn't played right centre for a while and his defence might not be as good as the other 3 candidates.
 
Last edited:
1. Woods
6. Teaupa
7. Conti
9. Haywood
13. Galvin
14. Young - gun hooker

Woods having a doggy hamstring is the main issue.
 
Hayward is very good at lock.

Young is more of a specalist hooker and the closest thing to Harry Grant the Dogs are going to have for a while.

I think Galvin would make a great 80 minute lock.

Woods has played a lot of AFL, he loves running the ball, fullback might suit him, provided his hamstrings could handle the load.

Haywood is just the best option at hooker at present, O'Donnell in reserve grade is interesting, 2 runs for 13 metres, 3 tackle breaks, a line break and a try. But reserve grade defence is reserve grade standard.
 
Last edited:
Rinakama in the extended squad, I hope that he replaces Montoya.

I don't mind Montoya on the extended bench because he could have an impact and could play some backrow.

Broncos game will be tough I'll be happy with a one point win, off the back of 2 doddgy ref decisions and 3 lucky bounces which go our way.

If Montoya plays, I hope that he will be a lot better, he definately needs to be.
 
I recon we need to take the Boncos on up the middle in this game.

In good ball definately punch a few hard running forwards up the middle.

In yardage run at their halves, but make the next pass a short pass and come back to the half.

Pick a half, probably Reynolds and run at him all night.

If the Boncos compress their line, then pass, or if we have ok field postion kick early and to space.

We want to keep their outside backs out of the game, don't try to play around them, run at the halfs or just inside our outside.

Similar to the lines we ran against Penrith.

I am not 100% sure what went wrong against Parra and I don't want to watch that game again.

What i seem to remember is we needed to run harder, we needed to execute and we needed to defend mistakes.
 
Last edited:
If they do not beat the gronks tonight there definitely is an issue within the club .
The wingers are going to have to aim up tonight . They will be targeted by Reynolds . He is the man that needs to be neutralised as much as possible.
I'll say we win it, but it won't be a flogging. I'll say will be by 6 to 8 points.
 
I wouldn't say an issue.

If Montoya plays and doesn't play well, I'll be disappointed, becuase his selection must be questionable.

We definately need a win, but we also need show we are a genuine contender.

Canberra who had a great season last year are going even worse then we are.

IMO Galvin has improved our side and Presto is in great form, other players are not going as well as last aeason.

We got flogged by the Broncos in Brisbane last year, they are dangerous at home.

I am not expecting it to be easy, but I hope we can win.
 
Our chances of winning are higher when Max King, Kiraz and Hayes all play.

But we have Critter back and our fowards need to aim up.

The team are trying to win each week, but every week we need to earn the win.

Silly mistakes, sloppy errors, and bad decisions make it hard to earn the win.

Against Parra a slow ruck and a lot of holding down meant we needed to run harder and clearly win the contact.

And some of the dumb mistakes and bad decisions against Parra were diabolicial.

We needed to do our share of slowing down the PTB.

Who knows what sort of ref we will get this game. We need to adapt to the conditions and the ref.

Regardless on the names on paper, we need to earn the win.
 
Last edited:
We need to dig deep and have a crack in the second half.

I hope Cirro is changing is mind about Montoya.

6 errors , 6 penaities some of the very dumb.

Great kicking gane from Reynolds, but we have him the opportunities,
 
Some of our team are just not good enough and our defence is way below last years standard.

Scramble and speed of the scramble is down.

And this years standard is higher than last years.

In particular we drop the ball and the opposition doesn't.

Sometimes our sequence of plays is very predictable.
 
Last edited:
Hope score is decent at least not a massive flogging . Can't see a win here so far . Critter looks like not fully recovered.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top