melbcityguy
Club Legend
- Joined
- Oct 20, 2024
- Replies
- 4,077
I want garang kuol
By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.
Sign Up Now!I thought he was more of an attacking winger like Irankunda, Boyle, Mabil but I've not yet seen him play, so will take your word for it. Even 2 "proper" strikers in a squad of 26 feels light to me.Suto is also a striker.
This post is called common sense.View attachment 5936
My thoughts:
Gauci > Beach
Balard > Okon-Engstler
Sapsford > All forwards bar Irankunda
Bennie > Karacic
Rowles > Degenek, Geria
Degenek, Geria, Behich, Mabil all very meh.
Velupillay, Boyle, Juric very lucky.
I wanted to see T. Yengi.
If Suto can be brought in Segecic should have been a no brainer (spilt milk)
This squad feels very weak, particularly for depth.
Okon for Balard is a crime. Great to see Herrington. We know Juric will withdraw and Duke comes in.
So important Robertson is there. Maybe it's Toure being out but the attack looks lacklustre.
The forwards seems to be the contentious selections. I'm not sure who else would have made much difference?Honestly thought we 'd get to see T.Yengi. Doing well in Japan, Duke was constantly picked for less.
Should have been Tete, Sapsford and Iredale in a power vacuum. They're all good in their own right.The forwards seems to be the contentious selections. I'm not sure who else would have made much difference?
For the wings we have Metcalfe, McGree as first choice. Irankunda would be the alternative. The other guys are fringe for minutes off the bench. Any of the Aliga guys would be raw.
Up front is thin.
Injured
K Yengi
Toure
Dagostino
Botic
Form?
Sapsford 8 goals 4 A in 37 appearances. Lost his starting spot since Jan. I think probably the most unlucky at this point.
T Yengi 5 goals in 31 apps across two clubs
Goodwin not playing
Stama 8 goals 3 A in 33
Carter 1 goal 1 A in 15
Aliga guys
Rose 8 G in 21
Caputo 8 G in 20
Jovanovic 7 G in 18
Duke 2 G 2 A in 8
No one really stands out unfortunately. Not sure I am forgetting someone
I've just woken up and didn't notice Irvine was rested and Mabil was in. A spark lacks though. Maybe it's Toure. I think the unfamiliarity on some names there and call me crazy, alphabetical order, doesn't make me realise how good it is we picked Robertson.POV the squad comes out when I’m working and I’ve missed a whole discussion lol.
What’s Zac Sapsford gotta do to get picked? No Antonio Arena or Cristian Volpato either. Not sure what happened with those negotiations. Nishan Velupillay being there is an eyesore, he’s got two goals and one assist in this entire season.
I knew Ante Šuto would get picked and I’m all for it! As soon as it was revealed he’s part Aussie and moved to Hibs I knew we’d try and cap him. Nice to see Lucas Herrington in there too!
Morgan Freeman voice= They didn't.The big positives are Robertson, Herrington, Suto and Italiano. I hope they all get game time.
Definitely add that over to the WC squad thread too.Given the way the game has players, could even pick both - I'll share the full squad I'm using after I'm finalised. Lewis Miller is the only ? on me for the moment - based off squad breakdown, I think a Forward/Winger would be best to use. The only one I've added from the suggestions so far is Toure
Actually.. I'll share the 25 player squad I have at the moment - give me a sec, I'll type it up:
** = not in current squad
GOALKEEPERS
Paul Izzo
Mathew Ryan
Patrick Beach
DEFENDERS
Alessandro Circati
Harry Souttar **
Milos Degenek
Kye Rowles **
Cameron Burgess
Jordan Bos
Aziz Behich
Fran Karacic
Jason Geria
MIDFIELDERS
Cameron Devlin **
Aiden O'Neill
Connor Metcalfe
Max Ballard **
Ajdin Hrustic
Jackson Irvine **
Riley McGree
FORWARDS
Awer Mabil
Nestory Irankunda
Deni Juric
Martin Boyle
Mo Toure **
1 spot left
Can you stop with the common sense please?I want to see this XI:
McGree - Juric - Irankunda
Robertson - Yazbek
Bos ------------------------------------- Italiano
Herrington - Burgess - Circati
Ryan
If at all then it would seem so. I don't like it though that he can state in early may 'yep, I'd like to play, make way.'I’m guessing we’re holding out on capping Cristian Volpato till the World Cup? Kinda smart as that would tie him to us if he played at a World Cup.
AA and didnt happen this squad haha... maybe next squadAA or AL?