I don't care if the clubs are franchises or not. I watch the A League because the best players currently residing in Australia play for them.
And I like to watch the best players in action.
I feel that if you don't want to watch the best players in the country in action, even ocasionally, you are losing connection with Australian football.
I support Adelaide United because they are my home town team (we played in the NSL too!). The club started out of necessity, after the demise of WA Hellas, and Adelaide City pulling out of the nsl. The town had to have a team on the national stage, otherwise big football would have shrunk to state league clubs playing in front of 500 spectators.
Unlike Mono, I don't have a state league club to follow, being an anglo. The clubs I played for years ago are long gone and the remaining clubs don't interest me.
Australian soccer has always suffered because our clubs' tradition is weak. It can't compete with AFL clubs with 150 years of tradition.
Australian soccer clubs that are almost that old, eg Adamstown, Balgownie etc never developed into big clubs.
South Melbourne's much hyped tradition is not much really- even Adelaide City have been Oceania Club champions, it was pretty easy